Friday, January 12, 2007

Wah Guru! (May contain spoilers)

Allright, that's a dead give away. But then, you must call a spade a spade.

Since I watched the movie at the Apollo Hospitals charity premiere Thursday night, people have been asking me if it will be a big hit. I'm not sure. But unless you are Maniratnam, which I am not, I think it is hardly material.

Because Guru packs a decent punch, in sheer entertainment. Granted it begins slowly (though sizzlingly for Mallika Sherawat fans, which again, I am not) but picks up momentum like one of those trains that take forever to get into 100kmph. But once they get going, there's no stopping them.

Nevermind what they say, if you remove the very thin veil over the Gurukant Desai story (Abhishek Bachchan), you have Dirubhai Ambani. Guru, then, is the story of the rise of a middle class Indian to the ranks of a business tycoon, the means which he uses to get there and his justification of the same. Meanwhile, there is gentle romance, a little humour, some superlative moments, much courtroom drama, some drama outside the court, irresponsible rhetoric, excellent dileanation of character, brilliant cinematography (Rajeev Menon) and music (A.R.Rahman) that blends with the movie.

If you are going to watch the movie remember that the first half sags a bit. At times, you are even wondering what the point is. Istanbul, where the intital parts of the movie are shot, is pale. Probably deliberately so... India is where the colour is, India is where the vibrancy is and India is where Guru Kant Desai can become what he has. A technique that has been used with much success in other movies, I'm not sure it quite works here.

Clearly however, the moment that begins the movie is the scene in the running train where Aishwarya Rai bumps into Bachchan junior. The chemistry is evident right from the word go, only going on to brew more magic in subsequent scenes in the movie, portraying marital intimacy in the most subtle language. To be mentioned in particular are two scenes, one in which the couple have a friendly pummeling routine on the bed and the other, in the second half of the movie, a mature Ash and Abhishek reminiscence about their just-married days. Superlative!

Headmaster's son Guru Kant Desai builds his business brick by brick, destroying an elite competition to shambles with a carefully blended mixture of personal charisma, bribery, corruption and cheating. He climbs steadily up the ladder, building business after business, in his success, arrogating to dream for the entire nation. In that is his hubris, his downfall. It is also in Manik Das Gupta (Mithun Chakraborty), the Commie newspaper man, that Guru meets his downfall.

Ironic, given that it's Manik Das, brilliantly essayed by Mithun, and his paper, The Independent(Swatantra), that gives Guru his first big break. It is poetic justice that the man who fights against monopoly to give Guru his chance also turns back on his protege when he realises he is going down the same path. Mithun uses Madhavan, Shyam Saxena, a reporter who takes up the challenge of bringing Guru down to destabilise him. Neat performance by Madhavan, credit to director Manirathnam for not sterotyping him as a reporter, it is so easy to do so these days.

Justice, then, descends on Guru. He loses the faith of the people and suffers a stroke. The support of the masses is his adrenalin...and when that is withdrawn, when people turn against him, Guru collapses - nearly wholly. A very touching scene in the ICU follows as his twin daughters sing to him - again the touch of a classy director. Abhishek has some splendid Nayagan moments throughout the movie, but more so in his illness. I certainly think that the junior B has just been in the role of a lifetime and he has Maniratnam to thank for drawing out what must be innate, but truly well-hidden talent in him.

Significantly it is the aam junta that revive the flailing behemoth. The courtroom scene has its usual moments of humour, Roshan Seth playing the chief inquisitor. Seth has been a favourite right from the days of Bharat Ek Khoj and brief though his appearance might be, it certainly adds meat to the movie. The success of Guru, I think, is the manner in which its many well-oiled components orchestrate in harmony as one unit.

But then there is the movie's fatal flaw. A number of people who watched the movie along with me, began by enjoying the second half of the movie, but had revised their opinion by the time the movie ended. "Nice" became "O..kay." Primarily because in the crucial scene, the climax, they loose the connect that is essential between movie and audience. What snaps it off is the rhetoric that Guru uses to justify himself and his work... Can the great Indian middle class be expected to sympathise with a man who made himself a millionaire, clearly with a good measure of deceit and deception?

At the end of the day, Guru is still an entertainer, in it, are the elements of movie-making so wonderfully mixed that a discerning audience will stand up to applaud, "Wah Guru! Wah Mani!"


Ferrari Pirabhu gaaru thinks its a great movie too... Check his review.

Mysorean, however, sees differently...

Bharadwaj Rangan's conclusion...

Lakshmee is thoroughly impressed, with Gurubhai and Dhirubhai!

What Yogesh thinks, albeit in Marathi

Do let me know if you have a review... Will link up



Anonymous Mysorean said...

Mine please. For the other side of the movie!

4:16 pm

Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thanks! Considering that I can NEVER watch a movie until I know what its all about, I dont know what I would've done if not for this!!!
Great analysis...will tell you how I enjoyed/didnt the movie tomm...
Till then,
Ta! cheers

4:39 pm

Blogger None said...


ur in.


must watch, whether u like or not.and thanks for the kind words! :)


5:04 pm

Anonymous Krishna Shankar said...

Me: Did you read Ramya's comments about "Guru"
She: Hmmmm... very bad!
Me: Why?
She: Udane pakkanum pola irukku! This is the problem with Tuticorin
Me: ????????

4:06 pm

Blogger yogesh said...

My review is here...
I didn't like this movie, compared to Mani's other movies...

Unfortunately my review is in Marathi...

Your review is nice...

10:13 am

Blogger Shyam said...

Dammit, after Prabhu's review and now yours, I SO want to see this movie! :( Only I cant, b'cos Shrewsbury is too small a place for blockbuster Indian movies at the local theatre :( :(

Good review though.

5:01 pm

Blogger Harish said...

U tempt me a lot to see it :-)

11:20 am

Blogger Usha said...

Echo your thoughts!

Spare the court-room monologue towards the end i thought the movie carried on very well with a lovely dream-like quality, epitomizing struggle as always and with a hope that life is all good!

Applause to Mithun da for a stellar performance.

11:34 am

Blogger None said...


tuthikudi-la padam podalayo? :)


am afraid i cant read marathi, but will link u for those who can. thanks for stopping by...


after a decent lapse of time i'll send u a DVD shyam, which u can watch if you stll want to watch! :)btw, after that effort of remembering sudha's b'day all by myself, she acuses me of having brinda remind me! :(


really?! u actually want to watch the movie! ;)


Glad u agree with me...


3:03 pm

Blogger Karthik B.S. said...

CAN'T WAIT FOR GURU! ash and abhi! :)

3:11 pm

Blogger None said...


Ash and abhi? well, i can tell u there's more to this one, at least! :)


5:23 pm

Anonymous Krishna Shankar said...

We saw the movie yesterday and liked it, very inspiring. We avoid watching movies in Tuticorin because of the theatres and most importantly the welcome fragrance of nicotine inside the hall. People here love to smoke while watching films. Armed with a hand towel we broke the rule for Mani Sir's sake.

4:26 pm

Blogger None said...


i can imagine...i've had a couple of experiences in theatres tent kottais actually masquerading as theatres...
but, good for u!


5:35 pm

Blogger Lotus Reads said...

Hi, Ramya

Happy to have discovered your blog! I know what you mean about the last scene, it was kinda cheesy but at the same time, it was rowsing because he (Guru) doesn't deny what he did, just gave his reasons for doing so. It's probably quite unlike a typical Mani ending, but very filmi and suitably mellowdramatic, lol.

5:52 pm

Blogger Lotus Reads said...

Me again - sorry I was referring to the courtroom scene.

5:54 pm

Blogger None said...

lotus reads,

hey, loved going through ur blog! but, just wondering, dyu buy all your books or dyu get them from the library! :)
just reading vikram chandra's sacred games... you've read that?


4:47 pm

Blogger Lotus Reads said...

Hi, Ramya

Many of my books are gifted to me, some I buy's rare that I get any from the library ( I hate having to return a book!). I haven't read "Sacred Games" but I am going to a reading by the author on Feb 7, and being a Bombay girl, I am really looking forward to that!

8:01 am

Blogger Kasi Alagappan said...

Good Analysis of the movie there. The movie had left many unanswered questions and climax led to justification of Gurukant's deeds!

3:04 pm

Blogger None said...

lotus reads,

hey, that is so cool! a reading by vikram chandra?! I'd love to be there...
I'm in only 315 pages and I'd say it has its moments, but rambles quite endlessly...
But then, I felt the same about shantaram, but ended up liking it...U've done shantaram, surely?


3:59 pm

Blogger None said...


thanks for stopping by... so broadly did you like the movie?


4:04 pm

Blogger Escape.... Great Escape said...

The only thing i noticed in the movie was the the people took way too long to eat sweets... they kept chewing even pieces of jilebi like it was Wrigley...

Anyway the rest of the things i noticed are on my blog... idiotic movie to say the least abotu this much touted... much publicized.....

3:34 pm

Blogger Nandhu said...

some very good points esp about the late beginning of the movie. but i did like the maiya maiya song a lot. didnt expect it to see it on the title though. also, very little interval between the first two songs.

7:23 pm


Post a Comment

<< Home